X

Search Results

Searching....

11.2 Chemical Solvent Models

11.2.4 PCM Job Control

(April 13, 2024)

A PCM calculation is requested by setting SOLVENT_METHOD = PCM in the $rem section. As mentioned above, there are a variety of different theoretical models that fall within the PCM family, so additional fine-tuning may be required, as described below.

11.2.4.1 $pcm section

Most PCM job control is accomplished via options specified in the $pcm input section, which allows the user to specify which flavor of PCM will be used, which algorithm will be used to solve the PCM equations, and other options. The format of the $pcm section is analogous to that of the $rem section:

$pcm
   <Keyword>  <parameter/option>
$end

Note:  The following job control variables belong only in the $pcm section. Do not place them in the $rem section.

Theory
       Specifies the which polarizable continuum model will be used.
INPUT SECTION: $pcm
TYPE:
       STRING
DEFAULT:
       CPCM
OPTIONS:
       CPCM Conductor-like PCM with fε=(ε-1)/ε. COSMO Original conductor-like screening model with fε=(ε-1)/(ε+1/2). IEFPCM IEF-PCM with an asymmetric 𝐊 matrix. SSVPE SS(V)PE model, equivalent to IEF-PCM with a symmetric 𝐊 matrix.
RECOMMENDATION:
       The IEF-PCM/SS(V)PE model is more sophisticated model than either C-PCM or COSMO, and probably more appropriate for low-dielectric solvents, but it is also more computationally demanding. In high-dielectric solvents there is little difference between these models. Note that the keyword COSMO in this context simply affects the dielectric screening factor fε; to obtain the outlying charge correction suggested by Klamt, 625 Klamt A., Jonas V.
J. Chem. Phys.
(1996), 105, pp. 9972.
Link
, 62 Baldridge K., Klamt A.
J. Chem. Phys.
(1997), 106, pp. 6622.
Link
one should use SOLVENT_METHOD = COSMO rather than SOLVENT_METHOD = PCM; see Section 11.2.8.

Method
       Specifies which surface discretization method will be used.
INPUT SECTION: $pcm
TYPE:
       STRING
DEFAULT:
       SwiG
OPTIONS:
       SwiG Switching/Gaussian method ISwiG “Improved” Switching/Gaussian method with an alternative switching function Spherical Use a single, fixed sphere for the cavity surface. Fixed Use discretization point charges instead of smooth Gaussians.
RECOMMENDATION:
       Use of SwiG is recommended only because it is slightly more efficient than the switching function of ISwiG. On the other hand, ISwiG offers some conceptually more appealing features and may be superior in certain cases. Consult Refs.  683 Lange A. W., Herbert J. M.
J. Chem. Phys.
(2010), 133, pp. 244111.
Link
, 685 Lange A. W., Herbert J. M.
Chem. Phys. Lett.
(2011), 509, pp. 77.
Link
for a discussion of these differences. The Fixed option uses the Variable Tesserae Number (VTN) algorithm of Li and Jensen, 736 Li H., Jensen J. H.
J. Comput. Chem.
(2004), 25, pp. 1449.
Link
with Lebedev grid points. VTN uses point charges with no switching function or Gaussian blurring, and is therefore subject to discontinuities that may cause errors in analytic gradients and lead to slow convergence in geometry optimizations. 682 Lange A. W., Herbert J. M.
J. Phys. Chem. Lett.
(2010), 1, pp. 556.
Link
Its use is not recommended except to make contact with other calculations in the literature.

Solver
       Specifies the algorithm used to solve the PCM equations.
INPUT SECTION: $pcm
TYPE:
       STRING
DEFAULT:
       INVERSION
OPTIONS:
       INVERSION Direct matrix inversion CG Iterative conjugate gradient
RECOMMENDATION:
       Matrix inversion is faster for small solutes because it needs to be performed only once in a single-point calculation. However, the CG solver (which must be applied at each SCF iteration) is recommended if the number of discretization points approaches or exceeds 10,000. Linear-scaling options for large-scale MM/PCM and QM/MM/PCM calculations are discussed in Section 11.2.5.

SwitchThresh
       Threshold for discarding grid points on the cavity surface.
INPUT SECTION: $pcm
TYPE:
       INTEGER
DEFAULT:
       8
OPTIONS:
       n Discard grid points when the switching function is less than 10-n.
RECOMMENDATION:
       Use the default, which is found to avoid discontinuities within machine precision. Increasing n reduces the cost of PCM calculations but can introduce discontinuities in the potential energy surface. If the PCM part of the calculation becomes too expensive it is better to reduce the number of discretization points (HeavyPoints and HPoints, described below), or to use Solver = CG, than it is to adjust SwitchThresh.

Construction of the solute cavity is an important part of the model and users should consult the literature in this capacity, especially with regard to the radii used for the atomic spheres. The default values provided in Q-Chem correspond to the consensus choice that has emerged over several decades, namely, to use vdW radii {RvdW,A} scaled by a factor αvdW=1.2; see Eq. (11.4). The most widely-used set of vdW radii are those determined from crystallographic data by Bondi, 129 Bondi A.
J. Phys. Chem.
(1964), 68, pp. 441.
Link
although the radius for hydrogen was later adjusted to 1.1 Å, 1069 Rowland R. S., Taylor R.
J. Phys. Chem.
(1996), 100, pp. 7384.
Link
and radii for those main-group elements not addressed by Bondi were provided later. 796 Mantina M. et al.
J. Phys. Chem. A
(2009), 113, pp. 5806.
Link
This extended set of vdW is used by default in Q-Chem, and for simplicity we call these “Bondi radii” regardless of whether they come from Bondi’s original paper or the later work. Alternatively, atomic radii from the Universal Force Field (UFF) are available. 1033 Rappé A. K. et al.
J. Am. Chem. Soc.
(1992), 114, pp. 10024.
Link
The main appeal of UFF radii is that they are defined for all atoms of the periodic table, though the quality of these radii for PCM applications is unclear.

Finally, the user may specify his or her own radii for cavity construction using a $van_der_waals input section, the format for which is described in Section 11.2.10. No scaling factor is applied to user-defined radii. Note that R=0 is allowed for a particular atomic radius, in which case the atom in question is not used to construct the cavity surface. This feature facilitates the construction of “united atom” cavities, 69 Barone V., Cossi M., Tomasi J.
J. Chem. Phys.
(1997), 107, pp. 3210.
Link
in which the hydrogen atoms do not get their own spheres and the heavy-atom radii are increased to compensate. As an alternative to scaling the vdW radii {RvdW,A}, the user can choose to augment each of them with a probe radius Rprobe [see Eq. (11.4)] to obtain the SAS cavity.

Radii
       Specifies which set of atomic van der Waals radii will be used to define the solute cavity.
INPUT SECTION: $pcm
TYPE:
       STRING
DEFAULT:
       Bondi
OPTIONS:
       Bondi Use the (extended) set of Bondi radii. FF Use Lennard-Jones radii from a molecular mechanics force field. UFF Use radii from the Universal Force Field. Read Read the atomic radii from a $van_der_waals input section.
RECOMMENDATION:
       Bondi radii are widely used. The FF option requires the user to specify an MM force field using the FORCE_FIELD $rem variable, and also to define the atom types in the $molecule section (see Section 11.3). This is not required for UFF radii.

vdwScale
       Scaling factor for the atomic van der Waals radii used to define the solute cavity.
INPUT SECTION: $pcm
TYPE:
       FLOAT
DEFAULT:
       1.2
OPTIONS:
       α Use a scaling factor of α>0.
RECOMMENDATION:
       The default value is widely used in PCM calculations, although a value of 1.0 might be appropriate if using a solvent-accessible surface.

SASradius
       Form a “solvent accessible” surface with the given solvent probe radius.
INPUT SECTION: $pcm
TYPE:
       FLOAT
DEFAULT:
       0.0
OPTIONS:
       r Use a solvent probe radius of r, in Å.
RECOMMENDATION:
       The solvent probe radius is added to the scaled van der Waals radii of the solute atoms. A common solvent probe radius for water is 1.4 Å, but smaller values (0.2–0.5 Å) have also been used historically. 505 Herbert J. M.
Wiley Interdiscip. Rev.: Comput. Mol. Sci.
(2021), 11, pp. e1519.
Link

SurfaceType
       Selects the solute cavity surface construction.
INPUT SECTION: $pcm
TYPE:
       STRING
DEFAULT:
       VDW_SAS
OPTIONS:
       VDW_SAS van der Waals or solvent-accessible surface SES solvent-excluded surface
RECOMMENDATION:
       The vdW surface and the SAS are each comprised simply of atomic spheres and thus share a common option; the only difference is the specification of a solvent probe radius, SASradius. For a true vdW surface, the probe radius should be zero (which is the default), whereas for the SAS the atomic radii are traditionally not scaled, hence vdwScale should be set to 1.0 (which is not the default). For the SES, only SwiG discretization is available, but this can be used with any set of (scaled or unscaled) atomic radii, or with radii that are augmented by SASradius.

Historically, discretization of the cavity surface has involved “tessellation” methods that divide the cavity surface area into finite polygonal “tesserae”. (The GEPOL algorithm 934 Pascual-Ahuir J. L., Silla E., Tuñon I.
J. Comput. Chem.
(1994), 15, pp. 1127.
Link
is perhaps the most widely-used tessellation scheme.) Tessellation methods, however, suffer not only from discontinuities in the cavity surface area and solvation energy as a function of the nuclear coordinates, but in addition they lead to analytic energy gradients that are complicated to derive and implement. To avoid these problems, Q-Chem’s SwiG-PCM implementation 682 Lange A. W., Herbert J. M.
J. Phys. Chem. Lett.
(2010), 1, pp. 556.
Link
, 683 Lange A. W., Herbert J. M.
J. Chem. Phys.
(2010), 133, pp. 244111.
Link
, 685 Lange A. W., Herbert J. M.
Chem. Phys. Lett.
(2011), 509, pp. 77.
Link
uses Lebedev grids to discretize the atomic spheres. These are atom-centered grids with icosahedral symmetry, and may consist of anywhere from 26 to 5294 grid points per atomic sphere. The default values used by Q-Chem were selected based on extensive numerical tests, 683 Lange A. W., Herbert J. M.
J. Chem. Phys.
(2010), 133, pp. 244111.
Link
, 685 Lange A. W., Herbert J. M.
Chem. Phys. Lett.
(2011), 509, pp. 77.
Link
and they are looser for MM atoms (in MM/PCM or QM/MM/PCM jobs) than they are for QM atoms, reflecting the more complicated electrostatic potential that is generated by a QM density as compared to an MM point charge. For QM atoms, the default is to use N=110 points for hydrogen atoms and N=194 points for all other atoms, whereas for MM atoms the default is N=50 for hydrogen and N=110 for non-hydrogen. These default values exhibit good rotational invariance (<0.1 kcal/mol differences in ΔG when the molecule is rotated 683 Lange A. W., Herbert J. M.
J. Chem. Phys.
(2010), 133, pp. 244111.
Link
) and absolute solvation energies that typically lie within <1 kcal/mol of the N limit, 683 Lange A. W., Herbert J. M.
J. Chem. Phys.
(2010), 133, pp. 244111.
Link
, 685 Lange A. W., Herbert J. M.
Chem. Phys. Lett.
(2011), 509, pp. 77.
Link
at least for charge-neutral solutes.

Note that earlier versions of Q-Chem used denser grids by default. (In versions up to and including Q-Chem v. 4.2, the default was N=590 for all QM atoms, but was switched to N=302 beginning with v. 4.2.1. The defaults mentioned above are the current ones starting with v. 5.2.) However, grid errors of 0.5 kcal/mol are well within the intrinsic accuracy of ΔGsolvation for these models. Grid errors in solvatochromatic shifts for excitation energies tend to be 0.01–0.02 eV, which is well within the intrinsic accuracy of nearly any excited-state methodology. If questions about grid accuracy arise, we suggest using N=302 as a high-quality option and N=590 as an essentially converged option. 683 Lange A. W., Herbert J. M.
J. Chem. Phys.
(2010), 133, pp. 244111.
Link
, 685 Lange A. W., Herbert J. M.
Chem. Phys. Lett.
(2011), 509, pp. 77.
Link
For large molecules it may be necessary to reduce the number of grid points (e.g., to N=86) or to use linear-scaling solvers rather than matrix inversion, as discussed in Section 11.2.5.

Note:  The acceptable values for the number of Lebedev points per sphere are N=6, 26, 38, 50, 86, 110, 146, 170, 194, 302, 350, 434, 590, 770, 974, 1202, 1454, 1730, 2030, 2354, 2702, 3074, 3470, 3890, 4334, 4802, 5294.

HeavyPoints
       The number of Lebedev grid points to be placed non-hydrogen atoms in the QM system.
INPUT SECTION: $pcm
TYPE:
       INTEGER
DEFAULT:
       194
OPTIONS:
       Acceptable values are listed above.
RECOMMENDATION:
       Use the default for geometry optimizations. For absolute solvation energies, the user may want to examine convergence with respect to N.

HPoints
       The number of Lebedev grid points to be placed on H atoms in the QM system.
INPUT SECTION: $pcm
TYPE:
       INTEGER
DEFAULT:
       110
OPTIONS:
       Acceptable values are listed above.
RECOMMENDATION:
       Use the default for geometry optimizations. For absolute solvation energies, the user may want to examine convergence with respect to N.

MMHeavyPoints
       The number of Lebedev grid points to be placed on non-hydrogen atoms in the MM subsystem.
INPUT SECTION: $pcm
TYPE:
       INTEGER
DEFAULT:
       110
OPTIONS:
       Acceptable values are listed above.
RECOMMENDATION:
       Use the default for geometry optimizations. For absolute solvation energies, the user may want to examine convergence with respect to N. This option applies only to MM/PCM or QM/MM/PCM calculations.

MMHPoints
       The number of Lebedev grid points to be placed on H atoms in the MM subsystem.
INPUT SECTION: $pcm
TYPE:
       INTEGER
DEFAULT:
       50
OPTIONS:
       Acceptable values are listed above.
RECOMMENDATION:
       Use the default for geometry optimizations. For absolute solvation energies, the user may want to examine convergence with respect to N. This option applies only to MM/PCM or QM/MM/PCM calculations.

Especially for complicated molecules, the user may want to visualize the cavity surface. This can be accomplished by setting PrintLevel 2, which will trigger the generation of several .PQR files that describe the cavity surface. (These are written to the Q-Chem output file.) The .PQR format is similar to the common .PDB (Protein Data Bank) format, but also contains charge and radius information for each atom. One of the output .PQR files contains the charges computed in the PCM calculation and radii (in Å) that are half of the square root of the surface area represented by each surface grid point. Thus, in examining this representation of the surface, larger discretization points are associated with larger surface areas. A second .PQR file contains the solute’s electrostatic potential (in atomic units), in place of the charge information, and uses uniform radii for the grid points. These .PQR files can be visualized using various third-party software, including the freely-available Visual Molecular Dynamics (VMD) program,W. Humphrey, A. Dalke, and K. Schulten (1996), 15 which is particularly useful for coloring the .PQR surface grid points according to their charge, and sizing them according to their contribution to the molecular surface area. (Examples of such visualizations can be found in Ref.  682 Lange A. W., Herbert J. M.
J. Phys. Chem. Lett.
(2010), 1, pp. 556.
Link
.)

PrintLevel
       Controls the printing level during PCM calculations.
INPUT SECTION: $pcm
TYPE:
       INTEGER
DEFAULT:
       0
OPTIONS:
       0 Prints PCM energy and basic surface grid information. Minimal additional printing. 1 Level 0 plus PCM solute-solvent interaction energy components and Gauss’ Law error. 2 Level 1 plus surface grid switching parameters and a .PQR file for visualization of the cavity surface apparent surface charges. 3 Level 2 plus a .PQR file for visualization of the electrostatic potential at the surface grid created by the converged solute. 4 Level 3 plus additional surface grid information, electrostatic potential and apparent surface charges on each SCF cycle. 5 Level 4 plus extensive debugging information.
RECOMMENDATION:
       Use the default unless further information is desired.

Finally, note that setting Method to Spherical in the $pcm input selection requests the construction of a solute cavity consisting of a single, fixed sphere. This is generally not recommended but is occasionally useful for making contact with the results of Born models in the literature, or the Kirkwood-Onsager model discussed in Section 11.2.2. In this case, the cavity radius and its center must also be specified in the $pcm section. The keyword HeavyPoints controls the number of Lebedev grid points used to discretize the surface.

CavityRadius
       Specifies the solute cavity radius.
INPUT SECTION: $pcm
TYPE:
       FLOAT
DEFAULT:
       None
OPTIONS:
       R Use a radius of R, in Ångstroms.
RECOMMENDATION:
       None.

CavityCenter
       Specifies the center of the spherical solute cavity.
INPUT SECTION: $pcm
TYPE:
       FLOAT
DEFAULT:
       0.0 0.0 0.0
OPTIONS:
       x y z Coordinates of the cavity center, in Ångstroms.
RECOMMENDATION:
       The format is CavityCenter followed by three floating-point values, delineated by spaces. Uses the same coordinate system as the $molecule section.

11.2.4.2 Examples

Example 11.3  A basic example of using the PCMs: optimization of trifluoroethanol in water. The solvent dielectric is specified in the $solvent section, which is described below.

$comment
2023/4/5 Add geom_opt_driver optimize per #2954, [39888/qchem]
$end

$molecule
   0 1
   C    -0.245826    -0.351674    -0.019873
   C     0.244003     0.376569     1.241371
   O     0.862012    -0.527016     2.143243
   F     0.776783    -0.909300    -0.666009
   F    -0.858739     0.511576    -0.827287
   F    -1.108290    -1.303001     0.339419
   H    -0.587975     0.878499     1.736246
   H     0.963047     1.147195     0.961639
   H     0.191283    -1.098089     2.489052
$end

$rem
   JOBTYPE         OPT
   BASIS           6-31G*
   METHOD          B3LYP
   SOLVENT_METHOD  PCM
   geom_opt_driver optimize
$end

$pcm
   Theory          CPCM
   Method          SWIG
   Solver          Inversion
   HeavyPoints     194
   HPoints         194
   Radii           Bondi
   vdwScale        1.2
$end

$solvent
   Dielectric 78.39
$end

Example 11.4  PCM with a single spherical cavity, applied to H2O in acetonitrile. Compared to the Kirkwood-Onsager multipole expansion method, Example 11.2.2 on page 11.2.2.

$molecule
   0 1
   O       0.00000000     0.00000000     0.11722303
   H      -0.75908339     0.00000000    -0.46889211
   H       0.75908339     0.00000000    -0.46889211
$end

$rem
   METHOD            HF
   BASIS             6-31g**
   SOLVENT_METHOD    pcm
$end

$pcm
   method        spherical   ! single spherical cavity with 590 discretization points
   HeavyPoints   590
   CavityRadius  1.8         ! Solute Radius, in Angstrom
   CavityCenter  0.0 0.0 0.0 ! Will be at center of Standard Nuclear Orientation
   Theory        SSVPE
$end

$solvent
   Dielectric        35.9   !   Acetonitrile
$end

Finally, we consider an example of a united-atom cavity. Note that a user-defined vdW radius is supplied only for carbon, so the hydrogen radius is taken to be zero and thus the hydrogen atoms are not used to construct the cavity surface. (As mentioned above, the format for the $van_der_waals input section is discussion in Section 11.2.10).

Example 11.5  United-atom cavity construction for ethylene.

$comment
   Benzene (in benzene), with a united-atom cavity construction
   R = 2.28 A for carbon, R = 0 for hydrogen
$end

$molecule
   0 1
   C    1.38620    0.000000   0.000000
   C    0.69310    1.200484   0.000000
   C   -0.69310    1.200484   0.000000
   C   -1.38620    0.000000   0.000000
   C   -0.69310   -1.200484   0.000000
   C    0.69310   -1.200484   0.000000
   H    2.46180    0.000000   0.000000
   H    1.23090    2.131981   0.000000
   H   -1.23090    2.131981   0.000000
   H   -2.46180    0.000000   0.000000
   H   -1.23090   -2.131981   0.000000
   H    1.23090   -2.131981   0.000000
$end

$rem
   EXCHANGE        hf
   BASIS           6-31G*
   SOLVENT_METHOD  pcm
$end

$pcm
   theory          iefpcm   ! this is a synonym for ssvpe
   method          swig
   printlevel      1
   radii           read
$end

$solvent
   dielectric 2.27
$end

$van_der_waals
1
  6     2.28
  1     0.00
$end

11.2.4.3 $solvent section: Electrostatics Options

The solvent for PCM calculations is specified using the $solvent section, as documented in this section and the next one. Note that the $solvent section is also used to specify parameters for the Kirkwood-Onsager SCRF model (Section 11.2.2), and the particular options that can be listed in the $solvent section depend upon the value of SOLVENT_METHOD in the $rem section. A minimum requirement for a PCM calculation is that the $solvent section must specify the static dielectric constant (ε), and for nonequilibrium excited-state calculations the optical dielectric constant (εoptε) must be specified as well. There are default values that are appropriate for water, but for any other solvent these constants must be specified. These can either be specified individually, using the variables Dielectric and OpticalDielectric in the $solvent section, or they can be set to predefined values by setting SolventName equal to one of the named solvents that is given in Table 11.4.

Unlike the SMx models (Section 11.2.9), which also employ named solvents (specified in the $smx section), use of SolventName with a PCM serves only to specify the two dielectric constants. Nonelectrostatic interactions are not included in an automatic way, although they can be added in an ad hoc way as described in Section 11.2.4.4. The dielectric constants listed in Table 11.4 correspond to values at 20C. For water, this is slightly different than the default values of Dielectric and OpticalDielectric, which correspond to 25C. The latter two values are fully tunable, whereas the named solvents are limited to the pairs of values (ε, ε) listed in Table 11.4.

Dielectric
       Specifies the static dielectric constant for the PCM solvent.
INPUT SECTION: $solvent
TYPE:
       FLOAT
DEFAULT:
       78.39
OPTIONS:
       ε Use a dielectric constant ε>0.
RECOMMENDATION:
       The static (i.e., zero-frequency) dielectric constant is what is usually called “the” dielectric constant. The default corresponds to water at 25C.

OpticalDielectric
       Specifies the optical dielectric constant for the PCM solvent.
INPUT SECTION: $solvent
TYPE:
       FLOAT
DEFAULT:
       1.78
OPTIONS:
       ε Use an optical dielectric constant ε>0.
RECOMMENDATION:
       The default corresponds to water at 25C. Note that ε=n2, where n is the solvent’s index of refraction.

SolventName
       Specify both ε and ε for PCM calculations by naming the solvent.
INPUT SECTION: $solvent
TYPE:
       STRING
DEFAULT:
       NONE
OPTIONS:
       name Use values ε and ε corresponding to solvent name in Table 11.4.
RECOMMENDATION:
       The use of SolventName is incompatible with explicit specification of either Dielectric or OpticalDielectric.

SolventName ε ε SolventName ε ε SolventName ε ε
acetic_acid 6.2 1.37 dimethoxyethane 7.3 1.38 iodobenzene 4.7 1.62
acetone 21.1 1.36     1-2-dimethoxyethane isobutanol 18.1 1.40
acetonitrile 36.6 1.34     glyme     2-methyl-1-propanol
acetylacetone 26.5 1.45 dimethylacetamide 40.2 1.44 isopropanol 20.2 1.38
    pentane-2-4-dione dimethylaminobenzene 5.0 1.56     2-propanol
    2-4-pentanedione     n-n-dimethylaniline mesitylene 2.3 1.50
aniline 7.1 1.59 dimethylformamide 38.2 1.43     1-3-5-trimethylbenzene
    benzenamine     N-N-dimethylformamide methanol 33.0 1.33
anisole 4.4 1.52 dimethylsulfoxide 47.2 1.48 methyl_acetate 6.8 1.36
    methoxybenzene     DMSO     acetic_acid_methyl_ester
benzaldehyde 17.8 1.55 dioxane 2.2 1.42     methyl_ethanoate
benzene 2.3 1.50     1-4-dioxane nitrobenzene 35.6 1.55
benzonitrile 25.6 1.53 ethanol 25.3 1.36 nonane 2.0 1.41
benzyl_alcohol 13.7 1.54 ethanolamine 31.9 1.46     n-nonane
    phenyl_methanol     ethyl_acetate octanol 10.1 1.43
bromobenzene 5.5 1.56     ethyl_ethanoate     1-octanol
butanol 18.1 1.40     acetic_acid_ethyl_ester p-xylene 2.3 1.50
    1-butanol ethyl_acetoacetate 14.0 1.42     para-xylene
butanol 17.1 1.40     ethyl-3-oxobutanoate     1-4-dimethylbenzene
    sec-butanol     acetoacetic_acid_ethyl_ester pentane 1.8 1.36
butanone 18.6 1.38 ethyl_benzoate 6.2 1.51     n-pentane
    2-butanone     benzoic_acid_ethyl_ester 1-pentanol 15.1 1.41
    butan-2-one decane 2.0 1.41 2-pentanol 13.4 1.41
    methyl_ethyl_ketone     n-decane 3-pentanol 14.0 1.41
carbon_tetrachloride 2.2 1.46 ethyl_formate 8.7 1.36 2-pentanone 15.4 1.39
    tetrachloromethane     ethyl_methanoate     pentan-2-one
chlorobenzene 5.7 1.52     formic_acid_methyl_ester     methyl_propyl_ketone
chloroform 4.8 1.44 ethylene_glycol 42.8 1.43 phenol 13.4 1.54
    trichloromethane     1-2-ethanediol 1-propanol 20.8 1.39
cyclohexane 2.0 1.43 fluorobenzene 5.5 1.49 propanal 17.4 1.36
cyclohexanol 16.4 1.46 formamide 111.8 1.45     propionaldehyde
cyclohexanone 16.1 1.45 formic_acid 51.1 1.37 pyridine 13.3 1.51
1-1-dichloroethane 10.1 1.42 heptane 1.9 1.39 t-butanol 12.0 1.38
1-2-dichloroethane 10.4 1.44     n-heptane     tert-butanol
dichloromethane 8.9 1.42 heptanol 11.9 1.42     2-methyl-2-propanol
    methylene_chloride     1-heptanol tetrahydrofuran 7.5 1.40
diethylamine 3.7 1.39 hexane 1.9 1.37     THF
diethyl_ether 4.3 1.83     n-hexane toluene 2.4 1.50
diethyl_ketone 17.0 1.39 hexanol 13.6 1.42 triethylamine 2.4 1.40
    3-pentanone     1-hexanol     n-n-diethylethanamine
    pentan-3-one water 80.2 1.78
Table 11.4: Named solvents available for PCM calculations. (Indented names are synonyms.) Values for ε correspond to the most recent measurements at 20C (from Ref.  ) and values of ε correspond to the most recent measurement at 20C and λ=589 nm (from Ref.  ). Setting SolventName to one of these values specifies the two dielectric constants but does not stipulate any nonelectrostatic interactions.

11.2.4.4 $solvent section: Nonelectrostatic Options

A PCM describes only electrostatic interactions with the solute, based on the static dielectric constant (for the initial state) and possibly the optical dielectric constant in the case of a nonequilibrium excitation or ionization process. Nonelectrostatic interaction terms, 505 Herbert J. M.
Wiley Interdiscip. Rev.: Comput. Mol. Sci.
(2021), 11, pp. e1519.
Link
describing cavitation (Pauli repulsion) and dispersion interactions, for example, can be added in an ad hoc way but have not been specifically parameterized for PCMs. (For solvation models with automatic incorporation of nonelectrostatic terms, which are needed to obtain absolute solvation energies, see the SMx models in Section 11.2.9 or the CMIRS approach in Section 11.2.7.

To add nonelectrostatic interactions to a PCM calculation, use the $solvent section whose general form is shown below.

$solvent
   NonEls  <Option>
   NSolventAtoms <Number unique of solvent atoms>
   SolventAtom <Number1> <Number2> <Number3> <SASradius>
   SolventAtom <Number1> <Number2> <Number3> <SASradius>
   . . .
   <Keyword>  <parameter/option>
   . . .
$end

The keyword SolventAtom requires multiple parameters, whereas all other keywords require only a single parameter, including the Dielectric, OpticalDielectric, and SolventName options that were discussed above. The keyword SolventAtom requires multiple parameters, whereas all other keywords require only a single parameter. Whereas the dielectric constant is required for any PCM calculation (with a default value representing water), the nonelectrostatic parameters are optional and have only infrequently been added to these models. 251 Cramer C. J., Truhlar D. G.
Acc. Chem. Res.
(2009), 42, pp. 493.
Link
, 626 Klamt A. et al.
Acc. Chem. Res.
(2009), 42, pp. 489.
Link

The nonelectrostatic interactions currently available in Q-Chem are based on the work of Cossi et al., 243 Cossi M., Mennucci B., Cammi R.
J. Comput. Chem.
(1996), 17, pp. 57.
Link
and are computed outside of the SCF procedure used to determine the electrostatic interactions. The nonelectrostatic energy is highly dependent on the input parameters and can be extremely sensitive to the radii chosen to define the solute cavity. Accordingly, the inclusion of nonelectrostatic interactions is highly empirical and probably needs to be considered on a case-by-case basis. Following Ref.  243 Cossi M., Mennucci B., Cammi R.
J. Comput. Chem.
(1996), 17, pp. 57.
Link
, the cavitation energy is computed using the same solute cavity that is used to compute the electrostatic energy, whereas the dispersion/repulsion energy is computed using a SAS cavity definition.

The following keywords (in the $solvent section) are used to define nonelectrostatic parameters for PCM calculations.

NonEls
       Specifies what type of nonelectrostatic contributions to include.
INPUT SECTION: $solvent
TYPE:
       STRING
DEFAULT:
       None
OPTIONS:
       Cav Cavitation energy Buck Buckingham dispersion and repulsion energy from atomic number LJ Lennard-Jones dispersion and repulsion energy from force field BuckCav Buck + Cav LJCav LJ + Cav
RECOMMENDATION:
       A very limited set of parameters for the Buckingham potential is available at present.

NSolventAtoms
       The number of different types of atoms.
INPUT SECTION: $solvent
TYPE:
       INTEGER
DEFAULT:
       None
OPTIONS:
       N Specifies that there are N different types of atoms.
RECOMMENDATION:
       This keyword is necessary when NonEls = Buck, LJ, BuckCav, or LJCav. Methanol (CH3OH), for example, has three types of atoms (C, H, and O).

SolventAtom
       Specifies a unique solvent atom.
INPUT SECTION: $solvent
TYPE:
       Various
DEFAULT:
       None.
OPTIONS:
       Input (TYPE) Description Number1 (INTEGER): The atomic number of the atom Number2 (INTEGER): How many of this atom are in a solvent molecule Number3 (INTEGER): Force field atom type SASradius (FLOAT): Probe radius (in Å) for defining the solvent accessible surface
RECOMMENDATION:
       If not using LJ or LJCav, then Number3 should be set to 0. The SolventAtom keyword is necessary when NonEls = Buck, LJ, BuckCav, or LJCav

Temperature
       Specifies the solvent temperature.
INPUT SECTION: $solvent
TYPE:
       FLOAT
DEFAULT:
       300.0
OPTIONS:
       T Use a temperature of T, in Kelvin.
RECOMMENDATION:
       Used only for the cavitation energy.

Pressure
       Specifies the solvent pressure.
INPUT SECTION: $solvent
TYPE:
       FLOAT
DEFAULT:
       1.0
OPTIONS:
       P Use a pressure of P, in bar.
RECOMMENDATION:
       Used only for the cavitation energy.

SolventRho
       Specifies the solvent number density
INPUT SECTION: $solvent
TYPE:
       FLOAT
DEFAULT:
       Determined for water, based on temperature.
OPTIONS:
       ρ Use a density of ρ, in molecules/Å3.
RECOMMENDATION:
       Used only for the cavitation energy.

SolventRadius
       The radius of a solvent molecule of the PCM solvent.
INPUT SECTION: $solvent
TYPE:
       FLOAT
DEFAULT:
       None
OPTIONS:
       r Use a radius of r, in Å.
RECOMMENDATION:
       Used only for the cavitation energy.

The following example illustrates the use of the nonelectrostatic interactions.

Example 11.6  Optimization of trifluoroethanol in water using both electrostatic and nonelectrostatic PCM interactions. OPLS-AA parameters are used in the Lennard-Jones potential for dispersion and repulsion.

$molecule
   0 1
   C    -0.245826    -0.351674    -0.019873     23
   C     0.244003     0.376569     1.241371     22
   O     0.862012    -0.527016     2.143243     24
   F     0.776783    -0.909300    -0.666009     26
   F    -0.858739     0.511576    -0.827287     26
   F    -1.108290    -1.303001     0.339419     26
   H    -0.587975     0.878499     1.736246     27
   H     0.963047     1.147195     0.961639     27
   H     0.191283    -1.098089     2.489052     25
$end

$rem
   JOBTYPE        OPT
   BASIS          6-31G*
   METHOD         B3LYP
   SOLVENT_METHOD PCM
   FORCE_FIELD    OPLSAA
$end

$pcm
   Theory      CPCM
   Method      SWIG
   Solver      Inversion
   HeavyPoints 194
   HPoints     194
   Radii       Bondi
   vdwScale    1.2
$end

$solvent
   NonEls        LJCav
   NSolventAtoms 2
   SolventAtom   8 1 186 1.30
   SolventAtom   1 2 187 0.01
   SolventRadius 1.35
   Temperature   298.15
   Pressure      1.0
   SolventRho    0.03333
   Dielectric    78.39
$end

11.2.4.5 Job Control and Examples for Non-Equilibrium Solvation

The OpticalDielectric keyword in the $solvent section is needed for nonequilibrium calculations, or it can be set to a predefined value by specifying SolventName instead. The LR-PCM excitation energy is automatically calculated whenever the CIS/TDDFT calculations are performed with PCM, but it is turned off while the perturbation scheme is employed.

ChargeSeparation
       Partition fast and slow charges in solvent equilibrium state
INPUT SECTION: $pcm
TYPE:
       STRING
DEFAULT:
       No default.
OPTIONS:
       Marcus Do slow-fast charge separation with the Marcus partition. Pekar Do slow-fast charge separation with the Pekar partition.
RECOMMENDATION:
       Charge separation is used in conjunction with the StateSpecific keyword in $pcm.

StateSpecific
       Specifies which the state-specific PCM will be used.
INPUT SECTION: $pcm
TYPE:
       Various
DEFAULT:
       No default.
OPTIONS:
       Perturb Perform ptSS and ptLR for vertical excitations. External Perform self-consistent EI-SS-PCM to the excited state (for emission). Internal Perform self-consistent II-SS-PCM to the excited state (for emission or excitation).
RECOMMENDATION:
       Use for vertical excition energies ptSS-PCM or in very polar cases the nonequilibrium II-SS-PCM, and equilibrium EI-SS-PCM for emission energies of long-lived excited states.

TdNonEq
       Specify the self-consistent SS-PCM/TDDFT method to calculate the solvent effects on vertical absorption and emission in solution based on the constrained equilibrium principle for nonequilibrium solvation.
INPUT SECTION: $pcm
TYPE:
       INTEGER
DEFAULT:
       NONE
OPTIONS:
       1 Calculate nonequilibrium excited-state free energy in absorption based on the equilibrium ground-state reaction field via an RPA calculation at the ground-state geometry. 2 Calculate nonequilibrium excited-state free energy in absorption based on the nonequilibrium excited-state reaction field via an RPA calculation at the ground-state geometry. 3 Calculate equilibrium excited-state free energy in emission based on the equilibrium excited-state reaction field via an RPA calculation at the excited-state geometry. 4 Calculate nonequilibrium ground-state free energy in emission based on the nonequilibrium ground-state reaction field via a pure single-point energy calculation at the excited-state geometry.
RECOMMENDATION:
       Option 2 and 3 need to be iterated until the excited-state reaction field converges. Option 1 is the first iteration of option 2. After the equilibrium excited state reaction field of option 3 converges, option 4 is executed.

Example 11.7  LR-TDDFT/LR-C-PCM low-lying vertical excitation energy

$molecule
   0 1
   C    0  0  0.0
   O    0  0  1.21
$end

$rem
   EXCHANGE            B3LYP
   CIS_N_ROOTS         10
   CIS_SINGLETS        TRUE
   CIS_TRIPLETS        TRUE
   RPA                 TRUE
   BASIS               6-31+G*
   SOLVENT_METHOD      PCM
$end

$pcm
   Theory      CPCM
   Method      SWIG
   Solver      Inversion
   Radii       Bondi
$end

$solvent
   Dielectric         78.39
   OpticalDielectric  1.777849
$end

Example 11.8  PCM solvation effects on the vertical excitation energies of planar DMABN using the ptSS and ptLR methods.

$molecule
   0  1
   C     0.000046   -0.000398    1.904953
   C     1.210027    0.000379    1.186051
   C     1.214640   -0.000065   -0.194515
   C     0.000164   -0.000616   -0.933832
   C    -1.214349   -0.001557   -0.194687
   C    -1.209753   -0.001846    1.185775
   H     2.151949    0.001377    1.722018
   H     2.164371    0.000481   -0.709640
   H    -2.164082   -0.002008   -0.709781
   H    -2.151763   -0.002287    1.721615
   C    -0.000227    0.001061    3.325302
   N    -0.000475    0.002405    4.484321
   N     0.000053   -0.000156   -2.297372
   C    -1.258656    0.001284   -3.036994
   H    -1.041042    0.001615   -4.102376
   H    -1.860897   -0.885647   -2.811117
   H    -1.859247    0.889133   -2.810237
   C     1.258563   -0.000660   -3.037285
   H     1.860651    0.886208   -2.810755
   H     1.859362   -0.888604   -2.811461
   H     1.040664   -0.000097   -4.102609
$end

$rem
   EXCHANGE              LRC-wPBEPBE
   OMEGA                 260
   BASIS                 6-31G*
   CIS_N_ROOTS           10
   RPA                   2
   CIS_SINGLETS          1
   CIS_TRIPLETS          0
   CIS_RELAXED_DENSITY   TRUE
   SOLVENT_METHOD        PCM
$end

$pcm
   NonEquilibrium
   Theory                 IEFPCM
   StateSpecific          Perturb
$end

$solvent
   Dielectric             35.688000       ! Acetonitrile
   OpticalDielectric      1.806874
$end

Example 11.11.9  TDDFT with External Iteration SS-PCM for nitrate in acetonitrile.

$molecule
   -1 1
   N    -0.068642000000     -0.600693000000     -0.723424000000
   O     0.349666000000      0.711166000000      1.187490000000
   O    -0.948593000000      0.200668000000     -0.956940000000
   O     0.659040000000     -0.386002000000      0.402650000000
$end

$rem
   jobtype    ¯¯         sp
   method ¯¯             PBE0
   basis  ¯¯¯           3-21g
point_group_symmetry False
   cis_n_roots             2           ! Number of excited states
   cis_singlets            true
   cis_triplets            false
   rpa                     false       ! Tamm-Dancoff approximation
   cis_moments             true        ! Excited state multipole moments
   cis_relaxed_density     true        ! Excited state density relaxation
   solvent_method        ¯ pcm
$end

$pcm
   StateSpecific           External    ! Keyword for External Iteration SS-PCM
   LinearResponse          false       ! Switch of LR-PCM
$end

$solvent
   Dielectric              35.68800    ! Acetonitrile
   OpticalDielectric       1.806874
$end

@@@

$molecule
   read
$end

$rem
   jobtype ¯¯             sp
   method ¯¯             PBE0
   basis ¯¯¯             3-21g
point_group_symmetry False
   cis_n_roots             2
   cis_singlets            true
   cis_triplets            false
   rpa                     false
   cis_moments             true
   cis_relaxed_density     true
   solvent_method          pcm
$end

$pcm
   StateSpecific           External
   Eqsolv                  15          ! Max. Number of iterations
   Eqstate                 1           ! Ref. State to be equilibrated
   Eqs_Conv                4           ! Conv. criterion for SCF energy and surface charges
   EqState_Follow          true        ! State Following to remain on the same Ref. State
   LinearResponse          false
$end

$solvent
   Dielectric              35.68800    ! Acetonitrile
   OpticalDielectric       1.806874
$end

Example 11.11.10  TDDFT with Internal Iteration SS-PCM and the additional ground state calculation for vertical emission energies of nitrate in acetonitrile.

$molecule
   -1 1
   N    -0.068642000000     -0.600693000000     -0.723424000000
   O     0.349666000000      0.711166000000      1.187490000000
   O    -0.948593000000      0.200668000000     -0.956940000000
   O     0.659040000000     -0.386002000000      0.402650000000
$end

$rem
   jobtype ¯¯             sp
   method ¯¯             PBE0
   basis ¯¯¯             3-21g
point_group_symmetry False
   cis_n_roots             4           ! Number of excited states
   cis_singlets            true
   cis_triplets            false
   rpa                     false       ! Tamm-Dancoff approximation
   cis_moments             true        ! Excited state multipole moments
   cis_relaxed_density     true        ! Excited state density relaxation
   solvent_method          pcm
$end

$pcm
   StateSpecific           Internal    ! Keyword for Internal Iteration SS-PCM
   ChargeSeparation        MARCUS      ! Keyword for the charge separation
   InternalIteration       AEM(f)      ! Procedure (VEM(f), VEM(d), AEM(f), or AEM(d)) + state sequence (add e.g.: -state 1 3 1 0)
   Eqsolv                  10          ! Max. Number of iterations
   Eqstate                 1           ! Ref. State to be equilibrated
   Eqs_Conv                4           ! Conv. criterion for SCF energy and surface charges
   EqState_Follow          true        ! State Following to remain on the same Ref. State
   theory                  iefpcm      ! PCM Theory (else CPCM)
   rf_ptss_save            true        ! Save the eq. reaction field of Ref. State
   LinearResponse          false       ! Switch of LR-PCM
$end

$solvent
   Dielectric              35.68800    ! Acetonitrile
   OpticalDielectric       1.806874
$end

@@@

$molecule
   read
$end

$rem
   jobtype                 sp
   method ¯¯             PBE0
   basis                   3-21g
point_group_symmetry False
   solvent_method          pcm
$end

$pcm
   theory                  iefpcm
   rf_ptss_read            true        ! Flag to read the reaction field and do RF-ptSS calc
$end

$solvent
   Dielectric              35.68800    ! Acetonitrile
   OpticalDielectric       1.806874
$end


Example 11.11.11  SS-PCM/TDDFT low-lying vertical excitation energy based on the constrained equilibrium principle.

$molecule
  0 1
  C     0.00000000    0.00000000    0.00000000
  O     0.00000000    0.00000000    1.22027000
  C     1.28132052    0.00000000   -0.79367740
  H     2.14499626   -0.00083829   -0.12870724
  H     1.30455453   -0.88067608   -1.44302080
  H     1.30547296    0.88142003   -1.44198042
  C    -1.28127663    0.00458022   -0.79382239
  H    -2.14504139    0.00537545   -0.12895306
  H    -1.30703468   -0.87518579   -1.44430491
  H    -1.30295394    0.88686493   -1.44106115
$end

$rem
   METHOD              M062X
   BASIS               6-31+G*
   JOB_TYPE            sp
   RPA                 2
   DFT_D               D3
   cis_singlets        TRUE
   cis_triplets        FALSE
   cis_n_roots         5
   cis_state_deriv     1
   CIS_DYNAMIC_MEM     TRUE
   CIS_RELAXED_DENSITY TRUE
   CIS_MOMENTS         TRUE
   SOLVENT_METHOD      PCM
$end

$pcm
   Theory              SSVPE
   ChargeSeparation    Pekar
   StateSpecific       Perturb
   TdNonEq             1
$end

$solvent
   Dielectric          32.613
   OpticalDielectric   1.766
$end

@@@

$molecule
  read
$end

$rem
   METHOD              M062X
   BASIS               6-31+G*
   JOB_TYPE            sp
   RPA                 2
   DFT_D               D3
   cis_singlets        TRUE
   cis_triplets        FALSE
   cis_n_roots         5
   cis_state_deriv     1
   CIS_DYNAMIC_MEM     TRUE
   CIS_RELAXED_DENSITY TRUE
   CIS_MOMENTS         TRUE
   SOLVENT_METHOD      PCM
$end

$pcm
   Theory              SSVPE
   ChargeSeparation    Pekar
   StateSpecific       Perturb
   TdNonEq             2
$end

$solvent
   Dielectric          32.613
   OpticalDielectric   1.766
$end

Example 11.11.12  SS-PCM/TDDFT equilibrium excited-state free energy in emission based on the constrained equilibrium principle.

$molecule
  0 1
  C    0.00000000   -0.57624800    0.00000000
  H   -0.95773500   -1.10813200    0.00000000
  H    0.95773500   -1.10813200    0.00000000
  O    0.00000000    0.70921900    0.00000000
$end

$rem
  METHOD               M062X
  BASIS                6-31+G*
  CIS_N_ROOTS          5
  RPA                  2
  CIS_SINGLETS         1
  CIS_TRIPLETS         0
  CIS_DYNAMIC_MEM      TRUE
  CIS_RELAXED_DENSITY  TRUE
  SOLVENT_METHOD       PCM
  POP_MULLIKEN         -1
  CIS_MOMENTS          TRUE
  DFT_D                D3
  CIS_CONVERGENCE      5
  MAX_CIS_CYCLES       150
$end

$pcm
  Theory               SSVPE
  Method               SWIG
  ChargeSeparation     EXCITED
  StateSpecific        1
  TdNonEq              3
$end

$solvent
  Dielectric           78.5
  OpticalDielectric    1.778
$end

@@@

$molecule
  read
$end

$rem
  METHOD                M062X
  BASIS                 6-31+G*
  SOLVENT_METHOD        PCM
  POP_MULLIKEN          -1
  DFT_D                 D3
  SCF_CONVERGENCE       8
$end

$pcm
  Theory                SSVPE
  Method                SWIG
  ChargeSeparation      Pekar
  StateSpecific         Pekar
  TdNonEq               4
$end

$solvent
  Dielectric            78.5
  OpticalDielectric     1.778
$end

Example 11.13  SS-PCM/TDDFT nonequilibrium ground-state free energy in emission based on the constrained equilibrium principle.

$molecule
   0 1
   C    0.00000000   -0.57624800    0.00000000
   H   -0.95773500   -1.10813200    0.00000000
   H    0.95773500   -1.10813200    0.00000000
   O    0.00000000    0.70921900    0.00000000
$end

$rem
   METHOD           M062X
   BASIS            6-31+G(d)
   SOLVENT_METHOD   PCM
   POP_MULLIKEN     -1
   DFT_D            D3
$end

$pcm
   Theory            SSVPE
   Method            SWIG
   ChargeSeparation  Pekar
   StateSpecific     Pekar
   TdNonEq           4
$end

$solvent
   Dielectric 78.5
   OpticalDielectric 1.778
$end